Friday, October 17, 2008

Listening to What the Children Say...

I found this article very interesting because I am in a Kindergarten classroom, and I find myself listening to conversations similar to those in the article. I, am also curious to what the children are saying. Their answers and outlook on the world fascinate me. I found the concept of open-ended questions really interesting, because even when you ask questions, sometimes it is hard to accept the answers children give you, and you wait for an answer that matches your own ideal answer. That is something that I feel I need to get better with. Because being able to actually hear a child's answer as it is, is also a way of assessing what a child needs and what a child already has in their own personal database of knowledge. 
It's important when we are teaching to remember that we are always teaching children. We may be teaching math, science, reading, writing and social studies, but what matters the most is that we are teaching children. I really liked when the author said "the children were continually making natural connections, adding a structure of rules and traditions according to their own logic." That's also what education is, allowing children to connect their learning to something in their lives, so their learning is more valuable. This is similar to what John Dewey said about experiences and how all experiences need to be valued in teaching. The author also says "use this compelling material as a vehicle for examining his ideas of how the world works," is also saying to teach to their experiences. 
Another part about this article I found interesting was the issue with Frederick about the birthdays and the fact that he did not believe his mom had birthdays anymore. To me this part related to science, because Frederick had a huge misconception about birthdays. While birthdays may not be science, children still have misconceptions about concepts in science, and teachers need to work to change misconceptions. Although you cannot force a child to change his mind, teachers need to find ways to help with these misconceptions. 

4 comments:

nsatagaj said...

Hi Kara,

I'm with you. I'm working on getting better at accepting a child's answer as is and not always passing judgment right away.

Nicole

cmatteis15 said...

Great thoughts, Kara...I totally agree. It is funny because this year I am not in a classroom so I don't get to experience this as much, but I do actually get to see it a lot with my 5 year old neices. They are in Kindergarten and the ideas and explanations they come up with are phenominal. It is so fascinating to hear what they rationalize something as and how it plays out in their minds and in their lives. I don't feel the need to correct them or redirect them but that is because I get to enjoy this aspect of them outside of school. I think that it is definately more challenging to let the control go in the classroom and let the kids take the reins. In my multicultural class we were talking about how in Latino classrooms it is acceptable and common for kids to just interject with ideas and connections to the text and the teacher will just interweave this in. In our culture that isn't really "acceptable" as we know teaching, but I think Paley's article urges us to reconsider that and in fact, encourage this sort of interactions

Kim said...

So the example of Frederick also shows that science topics don't have to be taught just during "science time." If we are really listening to what our students are saying, then we are probably finding more teachable moments or points that we want to teach more on later on.

Andreaf said...

Hi Kara, I'm in a first grade classroom and it is so amusing to listen to the kids have conversations with each other. In some ways, I think it is useful because you can learn about their misconceptions without even asking a question. Their ideas can be a good jumping off point for future lessons. Seems like a good way to engage their curiosity.